Another catch and kill order for a great white shark?

Congratulations Australia! You have done it again. According to “The Australian” a catch and kill order has been issued for what is believed to be a great white shark that killed a surfer over the weekend.

The article states 35-year-old Chris Boyd, was attacked on Saturday morning by what’s believed to be a great white shark at the popular surf break Umbries off Gracetown, 270km southwest of Perth. Mr Boyd, originally from Queensland, was killed instantly when he was mauled by a great white shark while surfing at popular break “Umbies” off Gracetown, 270km south of Perth at about 9am WST yesterday

It then goes on to say that The state’s fisheries department issued a catch and kill order for the shark, saying there was an imminent threat of more attacks in the area. The fisheries department is quoted as saying they weren’t ”just going to randomly kill sharks – it depends on what they see”

This is ridiculous. What exactly are they going to see? Since they say that the shark that attacked Mr. Boyd was “believed” to be a great white shark, how exactly are they going to determine that a particular shark is the right one, if they don’t even know the species for certain? 

This is another typical reaction for a government agency. Do something, no matter how stupid, just to appear to be doing something.

Our heart goes out to the family of Mr. Boyd, but indiscriminately killing an animal is neither bringing Mr. Boyd back, nor is it making the ocean any safer for anyone else.

Cheers,

Martin Graf
CEO
Shark Diver


About Shark Diver. As a global leader in commercial shark diving and conservation initiatives Shark Diver has spent the past decade engaged for sharks around the world. Our blog highlights all aspects of both of these dynamic and shifting worlds. You can reach us directly at staff@sharkdiver.com

Great White Sharks playing cupid?

So what does it mean, when you meet a great white shark at Isla Guadalupe and have it look you straight into the eyes? Well, for 2 of our divers this year, David and Fabiola, it meant something very special. Here is a message I got from them just …

How is Guadalupe this season?

Our 2013 white shark season has been incredible so far and our divers are coming back excited. This is a trip report we just received from Robert Saipe.

Amazing Time at Isla Guadalupe! 

It’s been 2 weeks since we docked after an amazing adventure at Isla Guadalupe, but, each day, I still find more joy as I think about the experience that Shark Diver delivered.  When I booked my trip, all I really hoped for was a chance to see even one Great White up nice and close but from safety.  Who knew I’d come away with so much more?  I’ll try to relay the basics of my experience through these passages, but I know words can’t fully express how deeply thankful I am for meeting our Guadalupe friends!
The crew at Shark Diver really are the best.  Most people probably hope for great dives when they book, but I have to tell you that vacation time outside of the dives was wonderful too.  The crew, at all times, exemplified the words ‘professional’ and ‘caring’.  For me, the fun never stopped.  When I was in the water, I saw amazing sharks.  When I was out of the cages, I shared countless laughs and stories with crew and other divers.  I particularly enjoyed the evening chats with the crew.  It’s something special to know that, while the crew worked super hard for us, they were courteous, caring, fun, and, most importantly, ‘real’.  I never felt like I was in the company of staff who were just doing their job.  I instead felt like I was always having a great time with terrific people who were celebrating the joy with us. 
“White Shark!”  Ah, I’d read those words from other reviews, but now I completely appreciate the chant.  Someone would always accent the phrase each time one of our friends would come to visit.  On day one of our dives, it took only minutes before we had visitors.  Surprisingly enough, not all were of the same species though.  You can’t know much about things you’ve never yet considered, so I was amazed at the level of interaction we saw between one of our first sharks and a sea lion.  We’ve all seen countless footage of Great Whites breaching upon one of these for lunch, but what an incredible sight it was to see prey almost toying with the massive predator.  For nearly 15 minutes, we watched a sea lion swim around and actually follow a great white.  Maybe it was taunting the shark (quite speedy one-on-one), or maybe it was hiding in it’s trail, but one thing was a constant; both were very aware yet surprisingly fine with each other in proximity.  I’m sure this is wrong, but, in some moments, the calmness of their interaction almost resembled playing.  Of course, I wondered if that would change if one got, erm, suddenly hungry.
By my first dive, I had already seen two different Great Whites – wonderful start!  Dive Master Martin joined our initial trio in the cage, and it was nice to see him just as excited as we were.  Though all of his efforts were devoted to providing us a great and safe time, I thought it was very special to see his obvious love for these creatures too.  These are the kind of people I wanted to be on tour with – those who deeply care about these amazing sharks.
We had one-hour rotations, so it was never long before our next turn.  The weather was gorgeous, and the breaks were just enough to recharge, enjoy the sun, and get ready for the excitement again.  Perhaps we were lucky, but my cage team saw sharks from nice and close on absolutely all 5 dives that day.  Some stayed for hours, others just for minutes, but all showed their uniqueness.  I have always loved Great Whites, but, before this, I had never realized the impressive depth of their intelligence and personality.
By day two, my sleep patterns were fully adjusted, and I woke up feeling extra strong, definitely raring to go.  Of course, chef Mark’s hard work had something to do with that. I can’t tell you how nice it was to always have such wonderful food so we could always feel full, great and strong.  Every meal Mark and Carolyn served us on the journey was a 10.”
Some divers took breaks from their turns by day two which I think had a lot to do with the gorgeous weather and the fact that we’d already seen so much.  Around lunch, I skipped one rotation, however I did make up for that with an open spot later, so, again, I logged 5 one-hour dives.  This day was loaded with excitement.  Some of the previous day’s sharks returned, but we also saw several new ones, including Annika, the lone female we met on our trip.  I loved watching Chuggy, the battle-scarred but strong male as he entertained us with dozens of passes.  One unnamed Great White spent hours showing us his charisma.  Johnny, Reb, Diablo andAtlantis put quite a show on too.  I lost count of how many times these sharks came in for an ultra close look.  What wonderful, curious creatures they are.  It is an exceptionally profound experience to see a Great White so clearly in control of his domain yet totally willing to exchange a calm moment as you look each other in the eye.  Not once did I feel like they were looking at us to attack.  I had many chances to see their incredible power, but, at every moment, I felt like each instead looked at us more with curiosity, just like we had for them.  It was a wonderful time as, by day’s end, we’d identified a total of 7 Great Whites this day alone.
On day three, I awoke hoping to spend as much time in the water as I could.  I decided that, on all available dives, I would wait to see if anyone else wanted the open spots, but I would take them if no one else did.  Many did take breaks, so, in all, I was able to enjoy a whopping 7 dives that day.  The three I took in a row wore me down a bit, but, wow, they were fun!  These sharks revealed so much personality.  I find it almost disrespectful to say too much about individual experiences with them (after all, I don’t have their permission!), but let me say, “It really wouldn’t be possible to have closer interaction with Great Whites than I was given on this day.”  The eye-to-eye, close as imaginable interaction I had with one in particular will forever be more than just a memory for me; it’s a permanent celebration.  I will cherish the sense of joy and awe I felt from those moments forever.  Before this trip, I had never met anyone who had been lucky enough to have safely met but deeply interacted with a Great White.  What a blessing it is to be one of so few who has spent some time with them in a way where we were both completely safe and could share our curiosities.
On the very last dive, it was quiet for many minutes, but then two entertainers came for close-ups.  When the clang on our cage let us know it was time to go, I remember thinking, “How can I leave right now?  There’s a massive Great White swimming just a few feet in front of me.”  But then, I shared one last look and turned to the ladder with a smile.  After all, “What better final moment of the journey could I ask for!” 
Thank you Shark Diver!  I’ve no doubt I’ll be back soon.  This journey with you was absolutely amazing!
Rob Saipe.
Thank you for your great report and pictures! We enjoyed introducing you to our amazing friends and welcome you to our Shark Diver family.
Cheers,
Martin Graf
CEO 
Shark Diver

About Shark Diver. As a global leader in commercial shark diving and conservation initiatives Shark Diver has spent the past decade engaged for sharks around the world. Our blog highlights all aspects of both of these dynamic and shifting worlds. You can reach us directly at sharkoperations@gmail.com.

How do we identify the Great White Sharks?

We have over 370 individual Great White Shark identified at Guadalupe Island. The Marine Conservation Science Institute has been keeping track of these awesome animals since 2001. 

Lets look at what makes these unique and the methods we use to identify them. The first thing we determine is the sex of the sharks. Male sharks have claspers and Females don’t. 

Female Shark, no claspers

 

Male shark, claspers

 

Once we know the sex of the shark, we look at the pattern of the transition from the white belly to the grey top. This transition is like a fingerprint. We primarily look at 3 different areas of the Shark. The gills, pelvic area, and the tail. 

 

Lets look at this picture of a Great White Shark and identify it.

 

First we need to determine the sex of the shark. So lets take a closer look at the pelvic area. We can see that there are no claspers, so it is a female.

No claspers, = female shark.

Now that we know that is a female, we look through our database and try to match up the color pattern to the females we have in our database.

#262, Deb

 

I think we found a match #262, Deb, looks like a perfect match. What if we are not convinced? In that case we look at another area. How about the gills?

Left is our photo, right is our databese

As you can see, the color pattern on the gills matches as well, so we have a confirmed match. The shark in our picture is #262 “Deb”

Aside from the color pattern, we also look for mutilations. We have previously talked about the amazing healing ability of our sharks here, so we have to be careful to not use regular injuries as a sole means of identification. Here is a picture of”Bruce” with a big bite from another shark.

Just a year later, he barely showed any sign of that injury.

Unlike flesh-wounds, mutilations are permanent. We have many sharks that have some unique mutilations, like the famous “Lucy” with her mangled tail.

Lucy

However, even with mutilations we have to be careful. There are multiple sharks who may have similar mutilations, so we still have to make sure that we positively identify those sharks. At Guadalupe, “Andy”, “Chugey”, “Tzitzimitl”, and “Cori B” all have the top of their tail missing

There are other mutilations, like missing pieces of a pectoral, pelvic, or dorsal fin that can all be used as a preliminary identification, but like mentioned above, it’s never a sole means and always has to be confirmed by looking at the color pattern.

Many people, especially on social media are using “birth marks”, black spots on typically the white belly of the shark, to identify the sharks. Those are actually not birth marks at all, but rather copepods, a parasite that can move around and may disappear from a shark, so they are not a good way to identify our sharks. 

“Tzitzimitl” with copepods.

All of our divers receive a copy of the entire Photo ID Database witch contains every shark we have identified at Guadalupe Island.

 

 

Now that you know how to identify the sharks, you are ready to come shark diving with us. How great will it be when you watch “Shark Week” the next time and you’re able to say “this is the shark that swam right by me”. Our goal is not to simply get you face to face with Great White Sharks, but to also share everything we know about all the individual sharks we encounter. Some individuals we have known for 21 years and watched the grow from “little” 12 footers to well over 16 feet.

Some of our trips are hosted by Nicole Nasby-Lucaas, the scientist who keeps the database, where she shares her vast knowledge from years of researching Guadalupe’s Great White Sharks with our divers.

Call us at 619.887.4275 or email crew@sharkdiver.com for more information on our expeditions.

Let’s go shark diving!

Cheers,

Martin Graf

CEO Shark Diver

About Shark Diver. As a global leader in commercial shark diving and conservation initiatives Shark Diver has spent the past decade engaged for sharks around the world. Our blog highlights all aspects of both of these dynamic and shifting worlds. You can reach us directly at staff@sharkdiver.com.